New Blog Post

When Did Bedtime Become a Negotiation?

How modern parenting turned into hostage diplomacy—and how to take back control.

Once upon a time, bedtime was a simple affair. You brushed your teeth, were told “Goodnight”, and left to stare at your ceiling until sleep came. No snack trays, no three-story deals, no Spotify sleep playlist curated by a Scandinavian mindfulness coach. Just you, your bed, and maybe the occasional threat of “If I have to come back in there…”

Fast-forward to now—and bedtime in many households looks more like a tense UN summit.

There’s the “one more story” clause.
The “five more minutes and I promise I’ll sleep” amendment.
The “I need a different water bottle, this one has the wrong vibe” meltdown.

At some point, modern parenting morphed from “Here’s the bedtime” to “Let’s open negotiations.” And like many peace talks, it often ends in tears. (Usually yours.)

How did we get here?

Well, somewhere between attachment parenting, Pinterest-worthy routines, and a general fear of damaging our children emotionally, we started feeling guilty about saying “no.” Add to that a few viral Reels with whispery-voiced mums saying “Let them lead the bedtime” and it’s no wonder we’re being emotionally blackmailed by people who actually are not the parenting experts.

Let me be clear: empathy is essential. Boundaries are also essential. It is perfectly possible to be kind, loving, and firm without giving your child full control of the evening schedule.

Signs You’ve Entered Hostage Negotiation Territory:

• Your child has five stuffed animals, each of which requires a separate goodnight ceremony.

• You’re explaining to a 3-year-old why it’s not time for a snack at 8:46pm.

• You’ve said “Last story” six times, and each one has had a sequel.

• You’re hiding in the hallway whispering “Do NOT go back in there, they saw weakness.”

SleepGranny’s Bedtime Reset Plan (No Megaphone Required)

1. Set a time. Stick to it.
If bedtime is 7:30, that’s when the lights go off—not when negotiations begin.

2. One story. One song. One kiss. Done.
This is the bedtime triad. Your routine can be loving and predictable without being an opera.

3. Anticipate the stall tactics.
Drink of water? Already by the bed.
Forgotten teddy? Already waiting.
Sudden existential crisis about death? Kindly bookmarked for the morning.

4. Leave the room.
Yes, they may protest. Yes, they may call you back. No, this doesn’t make you a bad parent.
It makes you a consistent one.

5. And remember:
Children want limits. They test boundaries to check that they’re there. You're not mean for setting them—you’re reassuring. And if SleepGranny says it, you can believe it.

Modern parenting has a lot going for it—more empathy, more information, more organic snacks. But bedtime doesn't need to be a battleground or a TED Talk. You’re the adult. You get to say, “That’s enough for today.”

Because no one wins when bedtime takes longer than a Netflix movie.

If you need help book a call with me HERE